Fate of the “Boat People”
By Don Hardy
Galang Island rests quietly in the calm sea, indistinguishable from thousands of other green Indonesian islands near the Equator south of Singapore. For tens of thousands of Vietnamese "boat people," the United Nations refugee camp on this island represented a single, thin ray of hope. For most of those who boarded small, rickety boats to escape Vietnam after the war, in search of new and happier lives, Galang will not be what they hoped to find.
Laying a thick trail of oily diesel smoke low across the glassy sea, our noisy boat violates nature's tranquility as it slices toward the wooden dock on this tiny, emerald isle. One would never suspect this forested point of land protruding unassumingly from the warm ocean would be home to nearly 20,000 desperate people who had no idea what their futures would hold. They risked everything in the belief that their new lives, or the lives they hoped to live someday in another country, would prove better than those they left behind.
The people who arrived on Galang already passed a difficult test. They rolled the dice on a dangerous ocean voyage and won. Many others lost that gamble. Pirates troll the seas in search of easy prey, and often find it. Many Vietnamese were robbed, killed or raped shortly after they gathered their meager possessions and set off in the cloak of darkness in search of freedom and opportunity. A small shrine on the island pays tribute to three women who, after suffering the humiliation of rape during their journey, took their own lives.
SPECIAL NOTE JUNE 2007: We received the following note concerning the photo to the right. My name is John Nguyen, and to my suprise i found this picture of me and my friends in Galang Indonesia. I am the one in the middle of three. I stayed in Galang from 1991 - 1997 and I was sent to Pinang to live with my dad for a month. His name is Nguyen Tu Tam my father was send to a prison in Pinang for almost two year because he was part of the Anti - communism demonstration.. I am currently living in Grand Rapids Michigan with my family. I am an American Citizen now and i love the freedom. Thank you for the picture.
My seven Congressional staff colleagues and I were greeted warmly by camp staff and U.N. workers whose difficult job, beyond providing meager shelter, rations and minimal health care, is to determine which of those people arriving would qualify for refugee status and possible resettlement in other countries.
Those unable to prove themselves political refugees under United Nations definition -- and with no close relatives in other countries to sponsor them -- faced a bleak future. Some eventually returned to Vietnam, some remained for years in the camp, hoping against hope to someday be "saved." During my visit, most did not qualify for resettlement. Still, few of those rejected voluntarily return to the conditions that forced their exile.
At a briefing, the camp commander revealed that Galang was established at the end of the Vietnam war and built to house only a quarter of the population living there. At that point, the United States had accepted 82,060 of those who survived their ordeal and qualified for resettlement.
As of my visit in 1991, Canada had become home to 13,516 people, followed by Australia's acceptance of 6,470. Other countries had not stretched their arms as widely. Japan accepted only 113 people. Spain, Italy, Argentina and Ireland had taken fewer than 20 each. Meanwhile, scores of people continued to arrive from the open sea on overloaded vessels. An additional 50 babies were being born in the camp each month.
Difficulties for Galang refugees intensified as many nations strengthened their resolve not to accept any more "boat people." Often the overloaded boats arriving in countries throughout southeast Asia were simply pushed back out to sea.
After our briefing, a security truck, red light flashing, led our caravan of four jeeps on a tour of the camp, two camps, actually -- two camps, and a cemetery on the side of a hill known as Camp Three.
Light rain fell as we stopped to talk with people and take pictures of small roadside shops. Other than money brought with them or funds sent by relatives the refugees were without financial resources and had very limited opportunity to earn money. But the prospect of minimal sales to each other and to island visitors maintained a few tiny food stands and small, wooden stores carrying basic supplies.
There was the hollow expression of resignation and sadness on some of the older faces, but not the children's. Excited by the parade of visitors, they eagerly posed for pictures and hesitatingly tried out English phrases they learned in school. Giggled calls of, "Good morning, sir," or "Nice afternoon, sir," rang out recognizably from the noisy chatter as we shuffled self-consciously along the small road. Children returned our greetings with giggles and laughter.
Nearby, under a small open-air shelter, the serious business of casting fates was being conducted. A United Nations' employee, in this case a pleasant and caring attorney from Washington, interviewed each person who arrived, soon determining whether an applicant's qualifications for resettlement could be met -- whether the individual was to be "screened in" or "screened out."
Over time, that crucial decision made all the difference for tens of thousands of people. With the passage of time since the war, increasing numbers of applicants were found to be economic migrants, not refugees. Therefore they did not qualify for resettlement in the United States. The interview sometimes lasted more than an hour. Eighty percent of the time, in 1991, the decision rendered was unfavorable.
As we milled about and through interpreters spoke with people whose fates would soon be known, I spotted a pretty young girl in a clean white dress standing quietly by herself. She backed away as I approached, but before long agreed to a photo with me. Her voice was soft and quiet. She didn't smile.
She was a small seven years old. I asked if her parents were also in the camp. She didn't answer immediately, but finally spoke quietly and unemotionally. The interpreter hesitated, then said, "This little girl doesn't know where her parents are." My throat was tied in a knot as I tried not to speculate on their fate. When I looked down at the innocent little face and started to ask another question, I found myself unable to continue.
Walking slowly down the dirt road, I pondered and cursed the distant political forces that brought the little girl, and tens of thousands of other people, to this place. I recalled a note pinned to flowers at the funeral for victims of the air disaster in Scotland several years earlier. Before that flight departed, a man waiting to board a different plane had met some of the passengers. After the crash he sent the note to an impromptu memorial. It said, "To the little girl in the red dress....you didn't deserve this." The little girl in the white dress that I had just met didn't deserve her fate either.
Our little caravan wound its way through the rest of the camp and past the place where a fifteen foot boa constrictor had been dragged from a small river by excited young men. A few minutes later we arrived back at the small pier. In a place where every person's prayer is to someday leave, I felt guilty that we, people who already had so much freedom and opportunity, would be the only passengers on the only boat departing that day.
After formalities and handshakes with camp officials, the boat's motor belched to life and we slowly pulled away. Standing on the deck, I strained to see the main camp. It was behind the hills and hidden from view, just as the pain of the people who lived there was hidden from world view.
As the island disappeared into the horizon, my long wave went unseen. As it slipped from view, I pondered the lives of the thousands of people who felt driven to literally cast their fates to the wind, not knowing whether Galang Island will be their first stop on the road to freedom, or their last.
I often think about and am haunted by Galang and the camp that is now closed. Eventually, some people's dreams of resettlement on other countries came true. Others were repatriated back to Vietnam and the lives they had escaped.
Most haunting is my memory of the quiet little dark-haired girl in the white dress. Just before our group left the processing center that day I spotted her again, walking down a dirt path. She stopped and we looked at each other without expression for a long moment. Just as she turned to walk away, a hesitant smile crossed her face. She raised her right hand in hesitant wave and was suddenly gone.
I could never forget that wet, hilly place at the opposite point on planet earth from where I sometimes fail to appreciate all my freedoms. I think often of that quiet little girl and try to imagine what became of her. It pains my mind and heart that I can never learn her fate, because I never even knew her name. I should have found a way, some way to bring her home with me, to give her a new life. Now I have to live with the fact I didn’t.
There are events in life that must be seen and felt by the heart to be truly absorbed -- and once fully understood have the power to fundamentally and forever change us. For me it is Galang, a distant island of burning hope and bitter despair.
Following is the text of an e-mail we received from a reader in Belgium, a Vietnamese man who spent his childhood on Galang Island. It provides a bright ray of happiness to a gray story.
Via e-mail from Belgium in May 2002
I was seven years old when I left Vietnam with my mother, sister and a friend of my mother. It was at night, in 1988. We were with 49 persons in a very small fishing boat. We sailed for eight days. There was not enough food but thank God we met two other boats who (gave) us some of their supply.
After eight days on the ocean, including one night in a big storm, we finally reached land. It was a military island. For two days they gave the women and children a place to sleep inside, but the men had to stay outside.
For food, the women had to cook for the soldiers. Very often we had no food for other people on our boat. My mother even had to eat rice that have become bad for many days, so my sister and I have enough good rice to eat. She washed that bad rice with sea water so the sour taste would come off.
After two days one person on the boat (I think the mother of our Captain) died.
The military wanted to send us back to the sea. Every woman and child begged the officer on their knees. We cried, begged and even kissed his shoes. (The soldiers) asked us for money, so they could buy new equipment for our boat. After we gave them our jewels they gave us the materials they had stolen from our own boat. (Then) with their big boat they pulled our fishing boat into the sea.
That night we thought they wanted to take the women to their boat, so we cut off the rope and our boat drifted to another island. One man lost his leg while he was pulling the boat to the shore. There were a lot of rocks there and his leg got caught between the boat and a rock.
On the island, near the water, there were some little houses of wood, but the island was uninhabited. The next morning our boat was totally destroyed by the water and big rocks.
We ate everything we could find there. We also found eggs of turtles: they were good, certainly when you're hungry. After three days the military came and took us with them back to their island. From there we were sent to Galang (refugee camp in Indonesia).
What we didn't know was that my mother was pregnant. After a few months I got another sister. Sha was born in Galang.
After one year my mother's friend got accepted by the Canadian government and left Galang.
My mother, sisters and I lived in Galang for two years. I remember everything: every street and building in Galang. I don't know if you have already seen it, but in Galang you have everything: groceries, some pubs, two movies, a Maria Church, two Buddhist temples, a hospital, school and post-office.
Every two weeks we got some rice, fish in cans, cooking oil and salt. Then we got in contact with my grandparents in Belgium and they sent us money (so we could grow) our own vegetables.
It wasn't luxurious but we were happy. Everybody helped another. It was very social. Each Saturday everybody had to clean the street and their room. I hope you have seen the place were the refugees lived. Only on Sunday we were allowed to go to the sea (shore). I think it was only two miles from the camp.
I didn't often go to school. Every day I went everywhere on the island. Maybe that's how I still remember every place. We kept our tradition: for example our New Year, in Vietnam, we normally make fireworks. In Galang we searched for wood and we made a big fire and we made a lot of noise with pots, pans, with everything we could find.
In Galang, on our part of the island, my mother was well respected. Every young person called her "mother". If they needed something, they asked her. She cooked for them and even gave them money if they wanted to go to pubs for a drink. There are a lot of good memories there that I would like to share with you. God, I miss those days!
After two years we got accepted to go to France. First we had to go to Singapore like everybody else who got accepted by any country. There we had to wait for a week for our plane to France. Singapore is a very beautiful city.
In France we stayed in Paris for three weeks in a refugee center. Then we went by car with our grandparents to Belgium. The whole trip from Vietnam to Belgium was a huge experience for me, something unforgettable.
My biggest dream would be go back to Galang for a while. Those two years were the best years of my life. There are a lot of refugees who experienced more bad, sad things than me.
My best wishes,